|
Participation of Placental Opioid-Enhancing Factor
in Opioid-Modulated Events at Parturition
Endogenous opioids play a significant role in mammalian parturition
as well as in the behaviors associated with delivery itself and toward
the emerging young. Distention of the uterus, and distention and mechanical
stimulation of the vaginal/cervical area are critical stimuli in the positive
feedback loop associated with expulsion of the fetus, and in the onset
of maternal behavior upon emergence of the fetus [9, 11, 25]. These stimuli
are sufficiently "stressful", "painful", or "aversive" so that they occur
during a period of elevated endogenous opioid levels and elevated pain
threshold [8, and see 12 for review]. Furthermore, the elevation of endogenous
opioids in certain brain areas at delivery, namely the ventral tegmental
area, is associated with the rapid onset of appropriate maternal caretaking
behavior at that time [24]. One might hypothesize that if endogenous opioids
facilitate maternal behavior and delivery, that the level of opioid present
would be the same for the optimization of both dimensions of parturition.
In fact, increasing pain threshold beyond that observed immediately prior
to delivery, in rats, by administration of exogenous opioid (morphine),
interferes
with the onset of proper maternal care [1, 10, 19, 21]. How then is antinociception
increased, at parturition, in a way that does not interfere with the expression
of proper maternal behavior?
Placenta and amniotic fluid contain a molecule(s) that potentiates the
antinociceptive action of opioids. We refer to this substance as POEF,
for Placental Opioid-Enhancing Factor. In an extensive series of experiments,
we elucidated many of the features of POEF [see 12 for review]. The following
is a summary of the findings of the early phase of POEF research:
-
Ingestion of either placenta or
amniotic fluid produces opioid-analgesia
enhancement (amniotic fluid is available to the mother before expulsion
of the fetus, whereas placenta is only available afterward)
-
POEF enhances pregnancy-mediated analgesia, as well
as that produced by footshock, morphine injection, pseudopregnancy, and
vaginal/cervical probing
-
POEF does not produce antinociception if administered
in the absence of opioid-mediated analgesia, despite the opioid content
of afterbirth materials
-
Enhanced antinociception is detectable in rats using
all assays tested (tail-flick, hot-water tail-immersion, formalin test,
hot-plate test)
-
POEF does not
enhance aspirin-induced [13] or nicotine-induced [18] antinociception in
naltrexone-treated rats, and is therefore apparently specific for opioid-mediated
antinociception
-
POEF must be ingested; it is apparently ineffective
if injected
-
The optimal amounts for enhancement of 3 mg/kg morphine
in rats: 1 placenta (500 mg) or .25 ml amniotic fluid.
-
Too high a dose of POEF may produce hyperalgesia
-
Enhancement in rats is detectable within 5 min after
ingestion and lasts 30 - 40 min
-
Male rats show enhancement of morphine antinociception
after ingestion of placenta
-
Human, bovine, and dolphin placenta contain POEF
activity (when tested in rats)
-
Bovine amniotic fluid contains POEF activity when
tested in cows [16]
-
Pregnant-rat liver does not
contain POEF activity
-
Ingested POEF enhances the central
antinociceptive action of morphine [5]
-
POEF apparently works by activating gut vagal receptors
-
Gastric vagotomy blocks the enhancing action of ingested
POEF on morphine antinociception [22]
-
Pretreatment with famotidine, an H2
histamine-receptor antagonist, to block digestion, does not block the POEF
effect [17]
-
During delivery, early amniotic-fluid treatment affects
tail-flick latency, contractions, and aggression, depending on time and
dose of treatment
-
Effects on other opioid-mediated phenomena:
-
morphine-induced hyperthermia is unaffected
-
contralateral circling after unilateral injection
of morphine into the ventral tegmentum is inhibited
-
morphine analgesia is produced by a normally subthreshold
dose in morphine tolerant rats
-
the effect of a low dose of morphine on amelioration
of withdrawal symptoms is enhanced
The question posed above, namely "How then is antinociception increased,
at parturition, in a way that does not interfere with the expression of
proper maternal behavior?" can be answered with our knowledge of POEF.
POEF provides for a potentiation of those aspects of opioid function that
enhance pain relief at delivery, but not those aspects that would interfere
with proper maternal care of the young. To confirm that hypothesis, we
[21] administered different doses of morphine systemically to postpartum
rats, in conjunction with either amniotic fluid (orogastrically) or saline.
We then examined both changes in pain threshold and changes in the quality
of maternal care. Fig. 1 shows that an injection of 2.0 mg/kg morphine,
in conjunction with an orogastric infusion of amniotic fluid, produces
a significant elevation of pain threshold, a level not significantly different
from the level produced by 3.0 mg/kg morphine (without amniotic fluid).
Fig. 2 shows though, that whereas an injection of 2.0 mg/kg morphine (either
with or without concurrent amniotic fluid) does not interfere with maternal
behavior, a dose of 3 mg/kg morphine (without amniotic fluid) dramatically
suppresses retrieval of the young by the mother. Retrieval is a key element
of appropriate early maternal care in rats, as it is in most altricial
species.
More recent research has focused on the differential effects of
POEF administration on various opioid-mediated phenomena (e.g., hyperthermia,
locomotor activation, antinociception, maternal retrieval). These differential
effects have led us to speculate that either POEF differentially modifies
different classes of opioid receptors, or has location-specific effects,
or both.
In an attempt to determine the extent to which POEF is opioid-receptor
specific, DiPirro has conducted a series of studies in which the effect
of ingested placenta was tested on rats receiving an intraventricular injection
of a specific opioid-receptor agonist [2, 3, 6]. The agonists used were
DPDPE for delta-opioid receptors; DAGO for mu-opioid receptors; and U-62066
(spiradoline) for kappa-opioid receptors. Different doses of agonist were
injected in a constant volume through indwelling intracerebroventricular
cannulae, and pain thresholds were assessed at peak agonist effect, using
a 52° C hotplate, after ingestion of 1g of placenta or meat control.
No repeated measures were used.
DPDPE -- The effect of placenta (and presumably POEF)
ingestion on delta-opioid antinociception produced by an intracerebroventricular
injection of DPDPE is presented in the next figure (Fig. 3):
Clearly, placenta ingestion potentiated the effect of delta-opioid mediated
antinociception produced by DPDPE. Without placenta, DPDPE did not produce
a significant elevation of pain threshold at a dose of 62 nmoles. Even
at 70 nmoles, the increase in pain threshold was minor. With placenta ingestion,
however, DPDPE produced a 250% increase in pain threshold at a dose of
62 nmoles.
DAGO -- The effect of placenta (and presumably POEF) ingestion
on mu-opioid-mediated antinociception produced by the administration of
DAGO can be seen in the following figure (Fig. 4):
The antinociceptive effect of DAGO alone (along with ingestion of meat
control) appears at the 0.29-nmole dose. At 0.39 nmoles, the antinociception
is quite pronounced. However, in combination with placenta ingestion, a
significant attenuation of DAGO-induced antinociception becomes apparent
at the 0.29-nmole dose, and the elevation of pain threshold produced by
0.39 nmoles DAGO is all but eliminated. Therefore, placenta (and presumably,
therefore, POEF) ingestion, blocks antinociception mediated by mu-opioid
receptors.
U-62066 -- The effect of placenta (and presumably POEF)
ingestion on kappa-opioid-mediated antinociception produced by central
administration of U-62066 (spiradoline) is illustrated in the following
figure (Fig. 5):
At the lowest dose of U-62 used, 100 nmoles, U-62 alone was clearly
ineffective, whereas U-62 in conjunction with placenta ingestion, produced
a significant elevation of pain threshold.
The effect of POEF on central opioid processes is almost certainly location
specific as well as receptor specific; very recent data indicate that antinociception
produced by morphine injected directly into the periaqueductal gray matter
is unaffected by placenta ingestion [4]. Opioid receptors are differentially
distributed, and clearly show different effects at different locations.
Bridges' work, for instance, has demonstrated that increased opioid levels
in the medial preoptic area interfere with maternal behavior [1, 10, 19].
In contrast, Thompson's recent work has shown that increasing the opioid
activity of the ventral tegmental area (by injecting morphine), which also
increases motivated behavior, facilitated the onset of maternal behavior
in inexperienced, nonpregnant rats. Conversely, blocking the effect of
morphine injection in the ventral tegmental area, by pretreating the rats
with the opiate antagonist naltrexone, blocked the facilitative effect
on maternal behavior of the intra-tegmental morphine injection. Furthermore,
interfering with the effect of endogenous opioids in the ventral
tegmental area at the end of parturition by intra-tegmental
injection of naltrexone methobromide, severely
inhibited the naturally-occurring onset of maternal behavior at that
time [24]. The following figure (Fig 6) shows the deleterious effect on
the rate of onset of maternal behavior, at parturition, of naltrexone methobromide
(quaternary naltrexone) injected into the ventral tegmental area.
Although POEF ingestion can modify the effects of intra-tegmental
morphine on locomotor behavior [24], we do not yet know if POEF ingestion
potentiates the effect of intra-VTA morphine on maternal behavior;
POEF, ingested in amniotic fluid, however, did not increase the effect
of a subthreshold systemic dose of morphine on maternal retrieval to the
point where it disrupted the retrieval of young by mother rats (see Fig.
2).
The mechanical stimulation and distention of the vaginal/cervical area
during expulsion of the fetus is well above the minimum amount necessary
to trigger pseudopregnancy in nonpregnant females experiencing elevated
estrogen levels. Yet the parturient rat does not enter pseudopregnancy,
but rather experiences a postpartum estrus and, if inseminated, a postpartum
pregnancy. We hypothesized, based on some supportive pilot data, that afterbirth
ingestion would decrease the likelihood that relatively intense vaginal/cervical
stimulation would induce pseudopregnancy. We tested this hypothesis in
a study [23] in which groups of nonpregnant rats received vaginal/cervical
stimulation of pressures of either 75, 125, 175 or 225 g. The stimulation
applied to the vaginal/cervical area, as expected [14], produced a dose-dependent
level of antinociception (measured as lengthening of tail-flick latency
or hot-water tail-withrawal latency). In addition, orogastric infusion
of amniotic fluid, shortly before the application of vaginal/cervical stimulation,
enhanced the level of antinociception produced by 125 g pressure. Interestingly,
the 225-g level of stimulation induced pseudopregnancy in 44% of the rats
receiving an orogastric infusion of saline, but only in 10% of the rats
infused with amniotic fluid. A detailed series of follow-up studies on
the effect of amniotic-fluid ingestion on pseudopregnancy induction is
currently being conducted by Patricia Abbott.
Mechanical stimulation during delivery, resulting from expulsion and
activity of the fetus, produces major activation of the pelvic, hypogastric
[15], and pudendal nerves. This afferent information, including nociceptive,
results in a central release of endogenous opioids. The opioids, in turn,
orchestrate a variety of parturitional phenomena including an elevation
of pain threshold, the onset of maternal caretaking behaviors, and even
perhaps a reduction in the likelihood that this vaginal/cervical stimulation
will induce pseudopregnancy, a condition that would eliminate the postpartum
estrus. Paradoxically, a higher level of endogenous opioids, despite producing
an apparently advantageous additional rise in pain threshold, would counteract
some other beneficial effects of opioids, especially those relating to
the emergence or performance of the complex of behaviors necessary for
caretaking of the young. However, it is apparent that a substance is available
in afterbirth material (POEF) that, when ingested by the mother,
potentiates
the antinociceptive actions of endogenous opioids (raising pain
threshold above that level produced solely by the opioids), but not
the actions that would, if increased, have a deleterious effect on maternal
behavior. This differential effect on certain opioid functions is the result
of selective action on some classes of opioid receptor (as well as some
degree of location specificity). Mu-opioid receptor activity, largely associated
with negative "side" effects of opioid activity, is suppressed by POEF,
whereas kappa- and delta-opioid-mediated phenomena are enhanced. This is
particularly interesting, and important, in light of recent studies showing
that kappa-opioid analgesics (and to a lesser extent delta-opioid analgesics)
are particularly effective in females [e.g., 7, 20].
REFERENCES
-
Bridges, R.S.; & Grimm, C.T. (1982). Reversal of morphine disruption
of maternal behavior by concurrent treatment with the opiate antagonist
naloxone. Science 218:166-168.
-
DiPirro, J.M. & Kristal, M.B. (1994). Analgesia produced by ICV
injection of DPDPE in rats is enhanced by placenta ingestion. Society
for Neuroscience Abstracts, 20, Part 1, 752.
-
DiPirro, J.M. & Kristal, M.B. (1997). Placenta ingestion facilitates
locomotion and antinociception induced by activation of delta-opioid receptors
in the rat. Society for Neuroscience Abstracts, 23, Part 1,
680.
-
DiPirro, J.M. & Kristal, M.B. (1998). The effect of placenta ingestion
on antinociception induced by morphine in the periaqueductal gray of the
rat. Society for Neuroscience Abstracts, 24, Part 1, 1132.
-
DiPirro, J.M., Thompson, A.C., & Kristal, M.B. (1991). Amniotic-fluid
ingestion enhances the central analgesic effect of morphine. Brain Research
Bulletin 26: 851-855.
-
DiPirro, J.M., Vanderwerf, T.M. & Kristal, M.B. (1996). The effect
of placenta ingestion on kappa-opioid antinociception in rats. Society
for Neuroscience Abstracts, 22, Part 2, 1365.
-
Gear, R.W.; Miaskowski, C; Gordon, N.C.; Paul, S.M.; Heller, P.H.; Levine,
J.D. (1996). Kappa-opioids produce significantly greater analgesia
in women than in men. Nature Medicine 2: 1248-1250.
-
Gintzler, A.R. (1990). Endorphin-mediated increase in pain threshold during
pregnancy. Science 210: 193-195.
-
Graber, G.C. & Kristal, M.B. (1977). Uterine distention facilitates
the onset of maternal behavior in pseudopregnant but not in cycling rats.
Physiology & Behavior 19: 133-137.
-
Grimm, C.T.; Bridges, R.S. (1983). Opiate regulation of maternal behavior
in the rat. Pharmacology Biochemistry & Behavior 19: 609-616.
-
Keverne, E.B.; Levy, F.; Poindron, P. & Lindsay, D.R. (1983). Vaginal
stimulation: An important determinant of maternal bonding in sheep. Science
219: 81-84.
-
Kristal, M.B. (1991). Enhancement of opioid-mediated analgesia: A solution
to the enigma of placentophagia.
Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews
15: 425-435.
-
Kristal, M.B., Tarapacki, J.A. & Barton, D. (1990). Amniotic
fluid ingestion enhances opioid-mediated but not nonopioid-mediated analgesia.
Physiology & Behavior 47: 79-81.
-
Kristal, M.B., Thompson, A.C., Heller, S.B., & Komisaruk, B.R. (1986).
Placenta ingestion enhances analgesia produced by vaginal/cervical stimulation
in rats. Physiology & Behavior 36: 1017-20.
-
Peters, L.C., Kristal, M.B., & Komisaruk, B.R. (1987). Sensory
innervation of the external and internal genitalia of he female rat.
Brain Research 408: 199-204.
-
Pinheiro Machado F° , L.C., Hurnik, J.F., & Burton, J.H. (1997).
The effect of amniotic fluid on the nociception of cows. Physiology
& Behavior 62: 1339-1344.
-
Robinson, T.M., Abbott, P. & Kristal, M.B. (1995) Blockade of
digestion by famotidine pretreatment does not interfere with the opioid-enhancing
effect of ingested amniotic fluid.
Physiology & Behavior 57:
261-263.
-
Robinson-Vanderwerf, T.M., DiPirro, J.M., Caggiula, A.R. & Kristal,
M.B. (1997). The analgesia-enhancing component of ingested amniotic
fluid does not affect nicotine-induced antinociception in naltrexone-treated
rats. Pharmacology Biochemistry & Behavior 58: 147-151.
-
Rubin, B.S.; Bridges, R.S. (1984). Disruption of ongoing maternal responsiveness
in rats by central administration of morphine sulfate. Brain Research
307: 91-97.
-
Sander, H.W.; Portoghese, P.S.; Gintzler, A.R. (1988). Spinal kappa-opiate
receptor involvement in the analgesia of pregnancy: Effects of intrathecal
nor-binaltorphimine, a kappa-selective antagonist. Brain Research
474: 343-347.
-
Tarapacki, J.A., Piech, M. & Kristal, M.B. (1995). Ingestion of amniotic
fluid by postpartum rats enhances morphine analgesia without liability
to maternal behavior.
Physiology & Behavior 57:209-212.
-
Tarapacki, J.A., Thompson, A.C. & Kristal, M.B. (1992). Gastric
vagotomy blocks opioid-analgesia enhancement produced by placenta ingestion.
Physiology & Behavior 52: 179-82.
-
Thompson, A.C., Ferguson, E.J., Abbott, P., Doerr, J.C. & Kristal,
M.B. (1991) Amniotic-fluid ingestion before vaginal/cervical stimulation
produces a dose-dependent enhancement of analgesia and blocks pseudopregnancy.
Physiology & Behavior
50: 11-15.
-
Thompson, A.C. & Kristal, M.B. (1996). Opioid stimulation in
the ventral tegmental area stimulates maternal behavior in rats.
Brain Research 743: 184-201.
-
Yeo, J.A.G. & Keverne, E.B. (1986). The importance of vaginal-cervical
stimulation for maternal behaviour in the rat. Physiology & Behavior
37:23-26.
|
Discussion
Board|
Previous
Page|
Your
Symposium |
|